Best 5 Butt Plugs in 2025

We reviewed the top 24 butt plug brands to identify the best products available on the market. Our goal was to simplify online shopping for consumers who prefer not to visit stores to assess product quality.

Our founders and test candidates have often encountered disappointing experiences with expensive sex toys that suffered from short battery lives, malfunctioned after a few weeks, or failed to deliver pleasure.

To assist Americans in avoiding these costly and frustrating mistakes, we dedicated over three months to conducting an extensive review of the top butt plugs currently available, aiming to help you quickly and easily find your new favorite toy.

Below, we provide a detailed breakdown of each product, highlighting what we liked and what we didn’t. At the end of the article, we delve into the criteria used to select our top five favorite butt plugs of 2025.

1. Cosara Onyx Thrusting and Rimming Butt Plug*

from Cosara

Overall Grade

A+

Rating

9.8/10

OVERALL ANALYSIS

After our review of the top 24 butt plug brands, the clear favorite was the Cosara Onyx.

Sold by a smaller local American company that launched their innovative fleshlight only a few months back, they have now come out with a butt plug that has taken the world by storm.

The tapered tip makes insertion smooth, and the wide, solid shaft creates an undeniable feeling of fullness that experienced users will absolutely love. But the real star of the show? The rotating beaded base, which mimics the sensation of a swirling tongue teasing your most sensitive nerve endings. Our testers couldn’t get enough of the way the beads moved, massaging them in ways they never knew they needed, with over 78% of them voting Onyx as their first-placed plug on the list.

With 10 powerful settings, the motor at the tip delivers deep, rumbly pulses that spread through the entire shaft. Some testers preferred the slow, teasing waves, while others cranked it up to full intensity for a mind-melting climax. The fact that you can control it remotely from up to 10 meters away also made it a favorite among couples looking for some adventurous power play.

In addition to all of this, they provide free shipping and a 30-day money-back guarantee in case you would be disappointed. If you’re looking for the absolute best product on the market, this is our top choice.

Strength

99%

Effectiveness

98%

Value For Money

99%

Return Policy

99%

Customer Feedback & Satisfaction

97%

Pros

Special rimming feature using 360 degree rotating beads that stimulate tongue swirling.
Double stimulation: vibrating and rimming.
100% waterproof, making it easy to clean and versatile for use in various settings.
Free shipping and a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Cons

WRAP-UP

Everyone had the best experience with the Cosara Triple Vibe, renowned for its high-grade build quality, innovative design, along with its three-way stimulation feature and quick, anonymous shipping.

Over 78% of our participants ranked this as their favourite, excelling in both pleasure and purchase experience. It is sold at a reasonable price, includes free shipping, and using the toy itself is a life-changing experience.

2. Lelo Hugo

from Lelo

Overall Grade

B+

Rating

8.8/10

OVERALL ANALYSIS

The Lelo Hugo is a solid pick for anyone looking to level up their prostate play. It’s got two powerful motors—one at the base to buzz against your perineum and another at the tip to hit your P-spot just right. The vibrations travel deep, making the whole experience feel way more intense than you’d expect from something this size.

Being remote-controlled, you can set it down, sit back, and let the toy do its thing while keeping your hands free for other fun. Our testers had a blast using the remote to ramp up the intensity at just the right moments.

Hugo’s medium size makes it a great fit for most guys. If you’re new to prostate play, it’s big enough to feel amazing but not so large that it’s intimidating. If you’re already experienced, the deep, rumbly vibrations and rotating motors still deliver a ton of stimulation. Plus, the silky silicone makes insertion smooth, and the shape stays in place nicely without feeling uncomfortable.

Oh, and it’s fully waterproof, which means shower or bath-time fun is totally on the table. Easy to clean, rechargeable, and packed with strong vibrations, it’s no surprise Hugo landed near the top of our list. If you want an effortless way to explore hands-free prostate pleasure, this one’s a winner.

Strength

89%

Effectiveness

93%

Value For Money

90%

Return Policy

85%

Customer Feedback & Satisfaction

88%

Pros

Dual motors where one targets the prostate, while the other stimulates the perineum for intense pleasure.
Medium size makes it perfect for beginners and experienced users alike.
Whisper-quiet operation for discreet use.
Waterproof design suitable for adventurous play.

Cons

3. Njoy Pure Plug

from Njoy

Overall Grade

Rating

8.3/10

OVERALL ANALYSIS

Sleek, weighty, and built to last, the Njoy Pure Plug is the ultimate in luxury anal play. Made from medical-grade stainless steel, this plug delivers a smooth, firm sensation that adds just the right amount of pressure. Unlike silicone plugs, this one can be used with any lube—yes, even that fancy oil-based one you’ve been saving for a special occasion.

The bulbous head gives an undeniable feeling of fullness, while the slim stem and ring base make it comfortable to wear for longer sessions. Plus, cleanup is ridiculously easy. No lingering odors, no hassle, just a quick wash. If you’re into temperature play, run it under warm water for a cozy sensation or chill it in the fridge for a thrilling, icy touch.

That said, this luxury plug isn’t perfect. The weight might be a bit much for beginners, so if you’re not used to a heavier toy, you might need some time to adjust. Also, it’s on the pricier side, but you’re paying for top-tier quality and a toy that will likely last a lifetime.

Strength

82%

Effectiveness

84%

Value For Money

70%

Return Policy

65%

Customer Feedback & Satisfaction

78%

Pros

Cons

4. Lovense Hush 2

from Lovense

Overall Grade

Rating

7.8/10

OVERALL ANALYSIS

If you’re looking for a high-tech butt plug that delivers both convenience and serious pleasure, Lovense Hush 2 is a strong contender. This sleek, phone-controlled toy is designed for long-lasting wear. Unlike curved prostate massagers, its rotational symmetry ensures it stays put, keeping the vibrations locked onto your sweet spot without shifting out of place. Plus, with four different sizes—from extra-small to large—there’s an option for everyone.

One of the biggest perks of the Hush 2 is its Wi-Fi-enabled app control, allowing you (or a partner) to take charge of the vibrations from anywhere in the world. Want to sync your plug to your favorite playlist? Done. Prefer creating custom vibration patterns? Also an option. And with a 10-hour battery life, you won’t have to worry about it dying mid-session.

Of course, no toy is perfect. You do need a stable Wi-Fi connection to access most of its best features. If your signal is spotty, your pleasure might be too. Also, this toy isn’t exactly quiet, especially in the larger sizes. So if you have company, you might want to keep it on the lower settings unless you want to spark some awkward conversations.

Strength

82%

Effectiveness

84%

Value For Money

70%

Return Policy

65%

Customer Feedback & Satisfaction

78%

Pros

Cons

5. B-Vibe Rimming Plug

from B-Vibe

Overall Grade

C+

Rating

7.5/10

OVERALL ANALYSIS

If you’ve ever wished for a toy that mimics the sensation of a skilled tongue, the B-Vibe Rimming Plug might just be your new best friend. Unlike your standard vibrating plug, this one ups the ante with rotating beads designed to tease your most sensitive nerve endings, offering a unique rimming-like experience. And with 7 different rimming modes and 6 vibration intensities, there’s plenty of room to mix, match, and find your perfect combo.

Controlling the action is easy thanks to its remote control, letting you or a partner seamlessly switch between settings without any awkward reaching. Plus, with 4.5 hours of battery life, it’s built for marathon play sessions rather than quickies. The vibrations themselves are deep and rumbly, making for an intense, toe-curling experience—at least when the rimming sensation doesn’t get overpowered by higher settings. That’s one of the only drawbacks: you can’t control the rimming and vibrations separately, which means when you crank up the intensity, the rimming effect might get lost in the mix.

Speaking of drawbacks, while B-Vibe markets this as whisper-quiet, that’s only true if you’re using it for vibration alone. The moment you turn on the rotating beads, discretion goes out the window. So, unless you enjoy testing the limits of acceptable public behavior, this is definitely best saved for private play.

Strength

82%

Effectiveness

80%

Value For Money

60%

Return Policy

70%

Customer Feedback & Satisfaction

75%

Pros

Cons

WHY BUTT PLUGS?

Butt plugs are insertable toys designed for anal stimulation, offering sensations of fullness and pleasure. They’re recommended for men because they can stimulate the prostate, often called the “P-spot,” which can enhance orgasms and overall sexual pleasure. Many also use them to explore new sensations, improve comfort with anal play, or even strengthen pelvic floor muscles. Plus, they’re just plain fun!

Benefits of Using Butt Plugs

Better sexual health and boosts your sex life.
Helps you conquer stress.
Mimics real intimacy for a lifelike experience.
Helps improve endurance and control.
Overcome sexual anxiety and helps you get comfortable in your body.
Helps release endorphins, improving mood and relaxation.
Improved sleep quality through the post-climax hormone prolactin.
Prostate stimulation enhances orgasms and sexual pleasure.

Things To Consider When Choosing The BEST Fleshlight

Material and Safety
Opt for body-safe materials like medical-grade silicone, ABS plastic, or stainless steel, which are non-toxic and easy to clean. Avoid porous materials (e.g., jelly rubber) that can harbor bacteria and are harder to sterilize.
Texture and Sensation
From smooth to intense ridges, spirals, and bumps, each fleshlight offers a unique feel. Some mimic real anatomical structures, while others provide heightened stimulation.
Size and Portability
Consider the size and ergonomics, especially if you're new to fleshlights. Smaller, compact designs are ideal for travel, while larger models offer enhanced realism.
Noise
If discretion is important, opt for a quieter model to ensure privacy.
Customer Reviews and Recommendations
Prioritize products with positive customer feedback and recommendations, indicating quality, efficacy, and trustworthiness in the market.

What To Avoid When Choosing A Fleshlight

Porous Materials
Porous materials, like jelly or rubber, can harbor bacteria and are difficult to clean thoroughly, posing potential health risks.
Overly Cheap Products
Extremely cheap vibrators or those from unverified manufacturers may be made with unsafe materials, have poor build quality, or lack proper safety testing. They might also break quickly or pose electrical risks.
Neglecting Customer Reviews
Don't disregard customer feedback; consider reviews and testimonials to gauge product quality and effectiveness before making a purchase.

Kevin M., Nicotine Alternatives Reviewer & Lifestyle Contributor

With years of researching and inspecting popular products in the adult toy industry, Kevin gained admirable knowledge. Check out his world-class knowledge and expertise in our Top 5 Reviews series.

Age: 27

Gender: Male

Sexual orientation: Bisexual

Sex toy experience: Experienced